The state House of Representatives voted 72-23 in favor of House Joint Resolution 587, which denounces the non-binding Agenda 21 plan adopted by a United Nations environmental conference two decades ago. read more
Top Stories
A right-leaning disgruntled Republican comments on the news of the day and any other thing he damn-well pleases.
The state House of Representatives voted 72-23 in favor of House Joint Resolution 587, which denounces the non-binding Agenda 21 plan adopted by a United Nations environmental conference two decades ago. read more
You can get your own copy of the Metro council meeting agenda at this link: Agenda. The agenda also links to the analysis. Council meetings can be really, really boring if you don't know what the Council is voting on. With an agenda and analysis, they are just really boring.
These are the bills to watch:
Ordinance No. BL2012-118 on first reading would provide property tax abatement for the Gaylord-Dollywood snow-water park. Usually bills on first reading pass unanimously without debate. This bill however is already proving controversial and I would not be surprised if one or two council members do not wish to be recorded as voting "no."
ORDINANCE NO. BL2011-83 by Councilman Stanley on second reading allows Metro water services to extend water lines to residential properties currently served by private wells. This bill was deferred by the council at the Feb. 7th Council meeting from that meeting to this meeting. The current policy is that expansion of water lines is the responsibility of a developer when developing new properties and that if an individual property owner wishes to access metro water and there is no water line in front of his property, then the property owner must pay the cost of the water line extension. While I feel sorry for those homeowners living with contaminated wells, I would hope the Council would thoughtfully consider this bill before voting for it. The cost of extending water to all 31 homes in Davidson County that are on private wells would be approximately $2 million. The director of finance has not certified that funds are available to implement this ordinance. See the analysis for the explanation of the bill. To see Councilman Stanley explain the bill, follow this link and see the video starting at 25:06.
ORDINANCE NO. BL2012-110 on second reading would permit the electronic filing of annual disclosure statements and benefits reporting statements. I don't see any argument against it and it is a good bill and should pass.
ORDINANCE NO. BL2012-115 on second reading would prohibit smoking on hospital grounds and within the public right-of-way in the vicinity of hospital entrances. Hospitals already ban smoking on their grounds and the city can and does ban smoking within 50 feet of the entrance to a hospital. This bill would expand that ban to 200 feet. I know smoking is an unhealthy habit, but simply walking past someone who is 50 feet down the sidewalk from the hospital entrance is not going to hurt anyone. We need to have a little tolerance and compassion for the smokers of society. I hope this bill does not pass. Surely there are some Council Members who feel this is government overreach. It will be interesting to see if anyone will stand up for smokers.
ORDINANCE NO. BL2012-116 on second reading is another of those bills that would provide property tax relief as a pay off for developing in Nashville.
Ordinance BL2012-88 by Councilman Claiborne on third reading amends the Metropolitan zoning code to add "non-self-imposed hardship" as a factor for the historic zoning commission to consider when determining whether to allow the demolition of a historic building. This will probably pass without dissent, however watch it. There is a new scrutiny of any bills that would expand or curtail private property rights or government planning and zoning authority.
Ordinance BL2012-92 sponsored by Council Members Dominy, Duvall, and others on third reading would expand private property protection for non conforming properties. It brings the code into conformity with state law that allows one to let a property cease operation for up to 30 continuous months before being required to comply with new zoning laws. The other thing this bill would do is to "toll" the 30 month period if the delay is due to litigation or natural disaster such as a flood. "Toll" is a legal term meaning to delay, suspend or hold off the effect of a statute. This is a good bill and needs to pass. Last council meeting this was adopted by a voice vote of the Council so it will probably pass without discussion or opposition. However, like the bill above this is one of those type of bills that is getting new scrutiny.
Ordinance BL2012-103 by Council Member Dominy on third reading is the controversial bill that would permit an asphalt plant to be built in Antioch but comes with lots of restrictions and protections. There has been considerable opposition to the the bill and an on-line petition drive. To view the public hearing on this bill from the March 6th meeting, follow this link and start viewing the video at 21:24.
I am taking the liberty of reposting the following letter from Ken Jakes to all members of the Metro Council and I am reposting the emails which were attached to Ken Jakes letter to the Council members. Since Ken Jakes has already widely distributed this information I am not considering it a private communications. I am however deleting the email address and phone numbers of "John and Vicky"
since they may not have wanted that information made public.
Ken Jakes is a frequent critic of Metro Government and a citizen activist discovering and exposing government corruption and waste. He is a former and probably future candidate for public office.
Members of our Council,
I was asked to respond to the forwarded email so let me share my thoughts and please consider.
To say that the 40% property tax on the Gaylord and Dollywood winter park is more then the vacant land is bringing into Metro at it's present tax rate is the wrong outlook. Any development in Nashville and Davidson County that would take vacant land and build structures, buildings, parking, etc. will bring in more revenue then in it's present state. If this is the approach the Council will take on development, are you going to approve on all development of vacant land to only charge 40% of the established Tax Rate ? I'm sure every hardware store, grocery store, and all other small business owners would love that approach, however I don't see that happening.
It is to the benefit of Gaylord to move this project forward because the land is already zoned for this project and to let the property set vacant is costing Gaylord revenues. When you talk about economic development and sales tax revenues that this project will provide, it is nothing in comparison to all the small business combined collectively together in Nashville and Davidson County who are struggling and paying more taxes. Every dollar of tax break provided to Gaylord and Dollywood has to be picked up by the remaining tax payers.
It is right that we can not predict the future, however I believe if we are going to assume, then we can assume if this practice continues that it will be nobody left but the BIG CORPORATIONS. Small business will fall and deteriorate, by being crushed by picking up the tax burden provided to the LARGE CORPORATIONS, because it was better then what we had.
Just for the record, my property at 2223 Whites Creek Pike, was vacant land that had been sitting for years until it was bought and Jakes Produce was built. The property has gone through the Council's process in Zoning, and I can assure you that the Davidson County Tax Office noticed the improvements and charge according to the established tax rate. Sure would have been nice if our Council had said, what the heck, cut the taxes 60% because it is better then what we had.
In closing let me just state the Administration in my opinion and I believe in your opinion, will be seeking a tax increase from the people. How would you explain to your constituents, Oh yea we need you to pay an increase but Gaylord and Dollywood got a decrease in taxes ? Something tells me that this will not go over very well.
I am just writing my opinion, however I believe it is the overwhelming opinion of the tax payers and constituents across Davidson County.
Members of our council, I hope you consider me to be genuine in my thoughts and at least you can state that Ken Jakes leaves no doubt where he stands. I would not care who would see where I stand on the issue. If you support the tax break for Gaylord and Dollywood can you do the same ?
Sincerely,
Ken Jakes.
___________________________________________________________________________________
From: "John Murphy"
The Tennessean, Mar. 13, 2012
A resolution branding a United Nations program encouraging sustainable development as a dark scheme to crush people’s property rights through “extreme environmentalism” goes to the Tennessee House for a vote on Thursday.
The legislation, HJR 0587, which refers to “Agenda 21,” is one of several pieces of legislation that has brought support from those who say development is too heavily regulated. Read more
Comment: I am still reading and learning, but not yet convinced that Agenda 21 is a plot for world domination. Everything from traffic roundabouts, to opposition to road expansions, to planning and zoning, to a preference for locally grown food, to conservation easements is being attributed to the influence of Agenda 21. Some of the opposition sounds pretty nutty.
On the other hand, some reasonable people make a compelling argument that Agenda 21 is a blueprint for restricting private property rights and expanding the authority of government and is a plan that will destroy our way of life. I am not ready to take a position but find the debate fascinating.
At the time of this posting, the article generated 41 comments on the Tennessean web page, almost all of them against Agenda 21. Read the comments to get a flavor for what the opposition is saying.
Unbelievable! Watch this and be disgusted. No shame. After winning a million dollar she says she still feels entitled to food stamps and is still struggling.
Tonya Miller turned in her petition today for State House District 53! This seat is being vacated by Janis Sontany who chose not to seek reelection. Tonya unsuccessfully ran against Janis in 2010. She has lots of contacts within the immigrant community and is bilingual and should poll well in the Hispanic community. Most of District 53 is in the Woodbine community.
Ken Jakes, frequent Metro critic and citizen activist knownfor exposing government waste and corruption, has made a freedom of information request of Mayor Karl Dean asking for, "all emails, letters, notes, or any other documents regarding the Winter Park by Gaylord and Dollywood from you, your office, Finance Department, Council Office, or any other department of the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County."
Ken has argued against the city's proposed incentive package saying, "our elected officials are set on giving our city away. If this project is going to produce revenues of 60 million a year as claimed", says Ken, "you can bet they will come anyway. Every dollar our city gives in tax break cuts, you and I the remaining tax payer gets to carry the burden."
Carol Swain |
Michael Paulsen is a professor at the University of St. Thomas School of Law and is among the nation’s leading scholars of constitutional interpretation.
Jim Blumstein is a professor at the Vanderbilt Medical School and director of Vanderbilt’s Health Policy Center.
Robert P. George is McCormick Professor of Jurisprudence and Director of the James Madison Program in American Ideals and Institutions at Princeton University.
by Ken Jakes
Ken Jakes |
March 11, 2012 by Don Surber, Daily Mail
So much for an ice-free Arctic. Most polar ice ever recorded
Wintley Phipps |